American Underdog: The Kurt Warner Story is a by-the-book sports biopic that would feel right at home on the Hallmark Channel.
If you know Kurt Warner’s story, then you already know that he is the greatest undrafted player in NFL history. Undrafted out of Northern Iowa and later released by the Green Bay Packers, Warner ended up stocking shelves at a Hy-Vee grocery store in Cedar Falls, Iowa. From there, he went onto the AFL, NFL Europe, and finally the St. Louis Rams. We all know what happens next: Trent Green’s injury forces Rams coach Dick Vermeil to name Warner as the starting QB. All along the way, Kurt’s wife, Brenda (Anna Paquin), and his family are the only people encouraging him to keep pursuing his dreams. The rest is history.
I have so many bones to pick that I do not even know where to start. Warner played three seasons with the Iowa Barnstormers but in watching the film, you’d have thought it was just one season. In truth, Warner signed as the Rams backup QB in 1998. However, the film makes it feel as though everything happens in 1999. Did they do this for the dramatic stakes? Maybe. Sure, American Underdog plays as a feel-good story but the script could make a better effort in showing these things being spread out.
It is 1999 when the film gets into Warner’s rookie season with the St. Louis Rams. However, I have no choice but to point out that the aerial view of downtown St. Louis begs to differ. I’m a St. Louis Cardinals fan. As such, I can spot the difference between the new stadium and the previous cookie cutter stadium. It is the old stadium that should be in this shot, not the new stadium. How the filmmakers can royally screw this up is beyond me! I’d like to say that this is what took me out of the film but I’d be lying. What took me out of the film is the casting of a transphobic actor.
It’s not lost on me that Levi is 41 years old and portrays Warner during his college years. This makes it all the more harder to buy into Levi portraying Warner during the Northern Iowa years. I get that Zachary Levi looks similar to Kurt Warner. In having Levi play Warner in college, he stands out in doing so.
If you’re a Kurt Warner fan, you’ll probably enjoy American Underdog.
DIRECTORS: The Erwin Brothers (Andrew Erwin and Jon Erwin)
SCREENWRITERS: Jon Erwin & David Aaron Cohen and Jon Gunn
CAST: Zachary Levi, Anna Paquin, Ser’Darius Blain, and Dennis Quaid
Lionsgate will release American Underdog: The Kurt Warner Story in theaters on December 25, 2021.
Please subscribe to Solzy at the Movies on Substack.
